Now that I've arguably settled in to the somewhat stressful, oftentimes bewildering, yet always entertaining employment opportunity that is the administrator of a public library, I feel that I'm seasoned enough to comment on my first official challenge to a book.
Well, almost official.
I was wrapping up the activities of another day in the dangerous stacks of the Thompson Public Library, finalizing the odds and ends of various avenues that are the sole forte and terrain of the library administrator, when he strolled in. Tall, assured, and armed with eyes of steel and the attitude that only comes from wearing a trucker hat indoors, he was a man on a mission, taking up a position. A missionary position, and the only position he could ever abide .
"Are you the new administrator?" he asked in a tone that suggested friendly intentions, yet masked a veneer of menace and confrontation.
"I am," I replied.
"Do you have a minute?"
"Sure," I said, and put down the Raymond Chandler novel I had been perusing.
All kidding aside, the gist of what he wanted from me was this: a children's picture book had met with his disapproval, and he wanted to make sure that I knew of his taking exception to its portrayal of a "deviant lifestyle."
The book was (and still is)
And Tango Makes Three, a charming picture book that has, according to the American Library Association, become the
most challenged book of 2006. Whoo-hoo! We hit the big time!
And what could this book be about, I wondered, my mind racing with the sorts of images one conjures up when confronted by the words "deviant lifestyle." Does it have full frontal? Full sideal? Is it naughty?

Actually, it's none of the above. Here's the
Wikipedia entry:
And Tango Makes Three is a children's book written by Peter Parnell and Justin Richardson and illustrated by Henry Cole, based on the true story of Roy and Silo, two male penguins in New York's Central Park Zoo, who, for a time, formed a couple. The book follows part of this time in the penguin's lives. This book teaches children that it's okay to be in or know someone who has an alternative family, not the "traditional" family.
The pair were observed trying to hatch a rock that resembled an egg. When zookeepers realized that Roy and Silo were both male, it occurred to them to give them the second egg of a mixed-sex penguin couple, a couple which had previously been unable to successfully hatch two eggs at once. Roy and Silo hatched and raised the healthy young chick, a female named "Tango" by keepers, together as a family.
Now, you tell me, isn't that the most adorable thing you've ever heard?
After the gentleman told me of his feelings in this matter - and he was a gentleman, despite our difference of opinion: I've just been having a little fun here - I patiently explained that, as a librarian, I hold to the basic tenets of freedom of speech, freedom of expression, and freedom of information (you know, all those things that, for some reason, really piss some people off). I informed him that, if he cared to make a formal complaint, he would need to make his views known in writing, and that I could then take the matter to the Library Board for serious discussion. Much to my disappointment, he refused, saying that he just wanted to make sure I was aware of his feelings. I thanked him, he left, and that was that.
Now, I know, just from watching Bill O'Reilly for ten minutes (I vomited up the remains of a particularly sticky meal shortly thereafter), that there exist certain persons for whom the very concept of personal beliefs beyond the narrow confines of their own warped perceptions is met with deep loathing and often violent convulsions. I cannot claim to be any different; there are many books on my shelves that I would gladly remove based on my own personal tastes and beliefs. But the difference between us is, I don't. I realize that there are many viewpoints, and we should celebrate them all, despite the difference of opinion.
For me, it all comes down to this: Would I rather be the right-wing fundamentalist lunatic
Pat Robertson, and endeavour to stomp out, squash, and destroy any opposing viewpoints , or librarian extraordinaire
Nancy Pearl, and believe that information should be available to all?
Tough choice.
"hominem unius libri timeo"— "I fear the man of a single book."Labels: book challenge, censorship, children's books, homosexuality, librarian, library, penguins, picture books, Public Library